Corporate social responsibility (CSR) holds that business owes society more than profit. This leans into the idea of proper treatment of employees, abiding by the law, ethical behavior, and giving back to the community. Archie Carroll's 1991 “Corporate Social Responsibility Pyramid” remains one of the most cited frameworks for companies to reference. Marketing teams are tasked with communicating a company's CSR commitments. This can put them in an uncomfortable situation when those commitments aren’t met.
This piece breaks down Carroll's four levels, how they apply to marketing specifically, and where companies tend to trip up when putting CSR into practice.
Carroll was a management professor who proposed that to be socially responsible, a business must meet economic, legal, ethical, and philanthropic expectations at a given point in time. The definition of CSR can be considered ubiquitous through Alexander Dahlsrud’s 2006 academic review, ”How corporate social responsibility is defined: an analysis of 37 definitions,” which examines the different interpretations of business literature
His 1991 paper introducing the pyramid remains, decades later, among the most downloaded articles in its field, and the model itself has been cited in academic work thousands of times. Carroll chose the pyramid shape deliberately as it illustrates that each level builds on the one below it, rather than functioning as four separate, unrelated checkboxes.
Carroll ranked the four responsibilities by importance rather than viewing them as equals. Economic responsibility is the base as the most fundamental, followed by legal and ethical responsibility, with philanthropic responsibility at the top as the least critical to a company's survival.
To start, a business has to be profitable. This is considered the starting point of the pyramid. Shareholders expect a return, employees expect to be paid, and customers expect a reliable product. Without profitability, a company cannot meet the required responsibilities. Companies need to also take into consideration cost-effective operations and marketing campaigns that don't rely on misleading claims to hit their numbers.
Businesses have a legal obligation to operate within the laws and regulations. They must uphold advertising standards and consumer protection rules and regulations. Ethical responsibilities oversee instances where the laws and regulations aren’t fully stated or when the majority don’t agree with the regulation.
In a marketing setting, ethical responsibilities are present in moments when the laws are rarely dictated directly. These moments consist of whether a company’s product is sustainable or not, respecting users’ privacy, and whether a campaign manipulates urgency or scarcity to mislead consumers.
The top of the pyramid encompasses the wants and needs of society, donations, community programs, and charitable partnerships. All of these are optional, but a company can be at risk of failing to be a good corporation if it skips one of the elements in the pyramid.
Some have criticized Carroll’s model. Economist Milton Friedman argues that social issues aren't a business’s concern. Markets that are left alone solve social problems more effectively than corporate intervention. Many business leaders still view CSR in this way today.
Another argument for Carroll’s model is that ethics shouldn’t have its own spot on the pyramid, but it should be incorporated at every level. A company’s economic decisions, legal compliance, and philanthropy are all under ethical decision-making. Most researchers concur that the four responsibilities work best together rather than separately.
A CSR strategy built around Carroll's pyramid needs to engage all four levels simultaneously.
Building a strong strategic plan begins with investors, employees, customers, suppliers, and the communities where a company operates. Here are a few practical steps to make this workable rather than aspirational:
Ongoing measurement is what separates a real CSR strategy from a press release.
The marketing team is responsible for researching concrete indicators, volunteer hours, emissions reductions, or donations. Transparent reporting is crucial. Regularly publishing progress and mentioning a company’s shortcomings creates trust with the public.
Though marketing campaigns and customer donation-matching programs operate efficiently, it only works well when they’re in an ongoing partnership instead of a one-off promotional launch.
LEGO is an example of how a company has incorporated the four levels of the pyramid. It has sourced environmentally friendly materials for its products and packaging, ensuring that it meets its sustainable goals and requirements. The sales team builds its 1-1-1 model directly into its business structure, donating 1% of product, equity, and employment time to non-profits.
Ben & Jerry’s is a certified B Corporation that also funds an independent foundation created to award grants to grassroots organizations. Levi’s created a supply chain code of conduct and has expanded worker well-being programs. Lastly, Starbucks built ethical sourcing standards for its coffee supply chain by partnering with different organizations.
Treating CSR levels as competing priorities instead of working together leads to failure. This can affect a company’s reputation if the different levels aren’t treated equally.
A few other challenges show up repeatedly, including:
Carroll's pyramid has held up for decades because it gives a company a structure for weighing responsibilities. Businesses that treat all four levels as ongoing commitments are the ones that are most likely to succeed.
Marketing teams shouldn’t just consider the philanthropic tier but should instead consider the economic, legal, and ethical foundations too. This in turn will strengthen the overall company and its campaign.